American Football Penalties: Rules, Types, Consequences, And Challenge System

The concept of penalties in American football is quite simple and easily understandable. It involves violations of the rules committed by players during the game. Committing penalties leads to consequences that can result in the loss of yards, downs, or favor the automatic advancement of downs for the opposing team.

Penalties can include actions such as holding and unnecessary violence, while the severity judgment and application of penalties are determined by the game’s referee.

Rules and Infractions

There is a wide variety of rules, with different natures and distinct infractions provided for in American football. Let’s get to know some of them.

Pass interference occurs when a defensive player makes contact with a receiver in an attempt to prevent them from receiving a pass. Pass interference can result in a 15-yard penalty, and the offense has the option to replay the down.

Grabbing the opposing player also constitutes a penalty and occurs when a defensive player grabs or holds an offensive player in an attempt to prevent them from blocking or running. Grabbing can result in a 10-yard penalty, and the offense has the option to replay the down.

Regarding unnecessary violence, this occurs when a player makes contact with another player in a way considered excessive or unnecessary. Unnecessary violence can result in a 15-yard penalty, and the offense has the option to replay the down.

There are also rules that encompass penalties not addressed by other specific rules. One of them is personal foul, which can result in the expulsion of the player. For example, when a defensive player makes unnecessary contact with the quarterback, this can be considered a personal foul. In this case, it can result in a 15-yard penalty and an automatic new set of downs.

Another personal foul is called “spearing,” which happens when a defensive player makes contact with the head or neck of an offensive player using the crown of the helmet.

An additional example is “illegal use of hands,” which occurs when a defensive player uses their hands to push, grab, or strike an offensive player, attempting to prevent them from blocking or running. Illegal use of hands can result in a 10-yard penalty.

Common Types of Penalties

Positioning Penalties

When we talk about positioning penalties in American football, we refer to infractions committed by improper movement or incorrect formation before the snap (start of the play).

There is a variety of penalties in this category. Let’s get to know some of them.

False Start: This occurs when an offensive player moves before the snap. This penalty usually happens due to the player’s anticipation to start the play and results in a 5-yard penalty against the offensive team.

Illegal Formation: It happens when the offensive team does not line up correctly before the snap. This can include having too few or too many players on the line of scrimmage or having players lined up improperly. This infraction results in a 5-yard penalty against the offensive team.

Offside: This occurs when a defensive player crosses the line of scrimmage before the snap. The player must be behind the line of scrimmage at the time of the snap, and committing this foul results in a 5-yard penalty against the defensive team.

Encroachment: Similar to Offside, it is an infraction committed by a defensive player who enters the neutral zone and disrupts the offense before the snap. This also results in a 5-yard penalty against the defensive team.

Delay of Game: This happens when the offensive team does not initiate the play within the time allowed by the league. The play clock is a critical part of the game, and the team has only a specific time to start the play after the referee’s whistle. Delay of Game results in a 5-yard penalty against the offensive team.

Physical Contact Penalties

These are penalties committed through illegal blocks, holds, interferences, and other improper contacts. The idea of these infractions is to protect the physical integrity of the players and ensure fair and safe play.

Illegal Block: This occurs when a player blocks an opponent in an illegal manner. There are different types of illegal blocks, such as blocking below the waist, blocking from behind, or blocking above the neck, which can result in different penalties.

Holding: This occurs when a player holds an opponent to prevent them from moving freely. Holding is a common penalty for both the offensive and defensive team and results in a 10-yard penalty against the team that committed the infraction.

Pass Interference: This happens when a player illegally prevents a receiver from receiving a pass. This can include pushing, pulling, or obstructing the receiver before the ball reaches them. Pass interference results in a 15-yard penalty and a new set of downs for the offensive team.

Roughing the Passer: This occurs when a defensive player makes excessive contact with the quarterback after they have thrown the ball. This penalty results in 15 yards and a new set of downs for the offensive team.

Unnecessary Roughness: This happens when a player makes excessive or unnecessary contact with an opponent. This foul can include late hits, hits to the neck or head, and other actions that are considered dangerous. Unnecessary roughness results in a 15-yard penalty.

Face Mask: This occurs when a player grabs an opponent’s helmet by the mask. This is a dangerous foul that can cause injuries and results in a 15-yard penalty.

Personal Conduct Penalties

These are infractions related to unsportsmanlike behavior, offensive language, fights, and the like. Without respect, penalties for personal conduct apply.

Unsportsmanlike Conduct: This occurs when a player acts in a provocative, disrespectful, or hostile manner toward opponents, referees, and spectators. Conducts such as taunting or excessive celebrations can result in penalties for unsportsmanlike conduct.

Offensive Language: This occurs when a player uses offensive language, insults, or obscene words directed at other players, referees, or spectators. These actions are considered unsportsmanlike and can lead to penalties for the offending team.

Fighting: This occurs when physical confrontations happen between players during the game. Fights are strictly prohibited in American football, and those involved may face severe penalties, including ejection from the game.

Unsportsmanlike Conduct: This includes various unsportsmanlike actions that do not fall under other categories. This may include, for example, purposefully delaying the game, simulating fouls, or other actions that violate the sportsmanship of the match.

Penalties and Consequences

Disciplinary measures are of paramount importance; their function is to maintain the integrity of the game, ensure the safety of those involved, and promote fair play. Penalties, regarding disciplinary measures, can result in repeating downs, loss of yards, nullification of plays, and others.

Loss of Yards: The offending team is penalized with the loss of yards on the field. For example, a 5-yard penalty pushes the offending team 5 yards back from where the foul occurred. This can be applied for infractions such as false start, delay of game, or holding.

Replay of Down: In some situations, the offending team may be penalized by replaying the down where the foul occurred. This usually happens when the infraction occurs during the offensive play, such as pass interference.

Nullification of Plays: In certain cases, a penalty may result in the nullification of a play, usually when the infraction occurs during a play where the offending team has gained significant yardage. In this case, the penalty invalidates the play, and the team is moved back from the point of the foul.

Automatic First Down: Some infractions, especially those committed by the defensive team, can result in an automatic advance of ten yards for the offensive team, granting them an automatic new set of downs.

Ejection: In severe cases of infractions or unsportsmanlike conduct, a player may be ejected from the game. This means the player can no longer participate in the match, and the offending team needs to substitute them with another player.

Penalties have a direct impact on the game’s result and the teams’ strategy. For example, penalties resulting in the gain or loss of yards for the offensive team can help advance on the field and get closer to the scoring zone. Conversely, the loss of yards can make it more challenging for the team to score.

There are also penalties that result in a change of possession, giving the opposing team a new offensive opportunity, thus increasing game control and creating scoring opportunities.

Offensive and defensive strategies are also greatly influenced by penalties. Imagine a 15-yard penalty happening against the defensive team; this can lead the offensive team to make more aggressive plays to take advantage of the field position. Similarly, the loss of downs can make the offensive team have a more conservative game to avoid errors.

Penalties can have a significant psychological impact on the game, affecting the team’s momentum. A penalty at a critical moment of the game can change the course of the match, leading to a shift in the game’s dynamics and the players’ mood (emotional state).

Time strategies are very common on the field. For example, there are penalties that influence the time and even stop it. This can allow a team to use more time to review their plays and run down the clock, preventing the opposing team from having time to score.

Play Revisions and Challenges

NFL coaches challenging a play on the field, demonstrating the use of the play review system to ensure accurate decisions during games

American football is a fast and exciting sport, but it is also quite complex and has many rules. Because of this, referees may occasionally make mistakes during games. To ensure greater accuracy in decisions, the NFL (National Football League) has implemented the play review system.

This system allows coaches to challenge certain plays, such as touchdowns, turnovers, and penalties. If the coach is correct in their challenge, the play is reviewed by a group of referees in a special review booth. These referees have access to replays from various angles, allowing them to carefully analyze the play in question and make a decision on its validity. In this way, play reviews help ensure fairness in decisions and ensure that the outcome of the matches is determined more accurately and reliably.

American football has a feature called “challenge,” where the coach has the right to challenge the referees’ decisions related to committed penalties. There are specific situations for using this challenge, such as when the coach believes that a touchdown, turnover, or field goal was incorrectly marked, when the penalty was incorrectly marked or not marked, or when the game should be restarted at a different point due to an error by the referees.

The coach has two challenges per game. If they win a challenge, they get an extra challenge. If they lose a challenge, they lose the extra challenge. To challenge a decision, the coach must run onto the field and signal to the field referee that they are contesting the decision. The field referee then reviews the play on a screen in the review booth.

The referees in the review booth review the play from various angles and decide whether the field referee’s decision was correct or not. If the referees in the review booth decide that the field referee’s decision was wrong, they will overturn the decision, and the game will be restarted. If they decide that the field referee’s decision was correct, the challenge will be lost, and the game will continue.

The consequence for losing a challenge is the loss of an extra challenge. If a coach loses their last challenge, they can no longer contest any decisions by the referees during the game. The challenge system has proven to be fair and accurate, contributing to the smooth running of the matches.

Understanding the intricacies of penalties in American football is essential for players, coaches, and avid fans. With a range of consequences, from yard losses to possession shifts, these penalties significantly impact game dynamics. By staying informed about the latest updates in penalty enforcement and the challenge system, enthusiasts can deepen their appreciation for this exhilarating sport.

Want More?

Click HERE to learn more!

Recommended articles:

American Football Penalties: Rules, Types, Consequences, and Challenge System